Skip to content. | Skip to navigation

Sections
Personal tools
You are here: Home Discussions Scale Case Study

Case Study

Hosted by Charles "Hipbone" Cameron (October 2007)

David Miles Hanschell is a primary school teacher on the Island of Bute in Scotland.  He is my friend and a considerable source of inspiration to me.  I want to introduce him to you, and to make him a "test case" to see what this community ccase studyan do to encourage and support a fine entrepreneur and his worthy social venture.

David was born and brought up in Barbados in the West Indies, and when he heard about the destruction of the neighboring island of Grenada in 2004's hurricane Ivan, he felt compelled to do something. With school closures, new builds and a continuous renewing of resources in Scottish schools he wanted to recycle the discarded textbooks, furniture, computers etc., and help Grenada at the same time.

Thus far, on his own initiative, he has been able to send four ocean freight containers of educational equipment out to Grenada, and is hoping to send more. Next week one of his containers will be filled with surplus from 14 primary (elementary) schools, and he already has three other 40-ft containers fully loaded and ready to go.

Through sheer persistent foot-slogging and networking, David now has a source of surplus ocean freight containers at no cost, is getting ISO certification for them, another company has offered him free storage capacity, and a large high school which is being totally re-equipped has offered him all their desks, chairs, book cases, whiteboards, and other furnishings without charge.  In addition, the Justice Dept. of the Scottish Office is providing him with youths to do community service by moving everything for him.  These are kids mostly from less favored socioeconomic backgrounds who grew up with his children in the neighborhood where he has lived for 17 years.

 Meanwhile, David says, there are schools all over the world that are under-resourced, where the children don't even have a desk to write at, let alone a chair to sit on.  And mountains of good quality surplus educational resources are ending up in landfill throughout Scotland and probably Europe.

As you see, David can do a great deal with enthusiasm and persistence: he has the entrepreneurial spirit in spades, but not the training of a businessman.  He's a Scottish schoolteacher with five months to go before retirement, at which point he wants to ramp up his efforts.  He's also untidy, unbureaucratic, not an "office person", wonderfully warm-hearted, and in need of support from someone who can talk him (patiently, he says) through the various aspects of taking a wonderful and desperately needed idea and establishing it, leveraging his existing efforts to create a revenue stream that can sustain and grow his campaign.

david henschell Now that David's story has inspired you, can you help him?  He needs:

:: support from people with business expertise and social conscience

:: help in evaluating his project, its strengths and weaknesses

:: to know where the project stands in terms of sustainability

:: where the project stands in terms of scaling up

:: support with all the administrative issues, business planning, presentation preparations etc related to the project, and

:: help in maintaining and updating his website.

Let's talk with David.  Let's see what we can do as a community.

David in Bute: Initial thoughts

Posted by Jeff Mowatt at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

First that David is probably a long way from the resources he'd like to recycle, being on a Scottish Island and that the website although giving a clear picture of what he was doing was incredibly slow to load, several minutes to reveal the home page. This might be easily remedied by transfer to another server.

My instinct is that David needs to seed the idea of what he's doing among other communities, rather than scale up his own operations. I'm thinking a "freecycle" approach specifically for school equipment rather than trying to build a pyramid of management.

In the same position, I'd be doing what I'm actually doing for other causes. Getting a message out to the largest possible audience. The social networking sites with users numbering millions, that have the tools to publicise events, link to fundraising tools and even perhaps building applications that generate revenue and engender brand loyalty through their social purpose.

Having etablished the community replication, then the logistics contacts can be brought to bear, with David becoming the shipping facilitator and mentor.

If it isn't already, I'd also be re-building the website under one of the opensource CMS products, just to make the editing task a clerical task rather than a coding one.

More later perhaps,

Jeff

David On Bute Replies

Posted by David Miles Hanschell at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

Many thanks Jeff for your suggestions for improving my web site.It was put together by a Friend and local digital artisan last yearas a means of supporting my initiative.All help from here on that will improve the site, so that it increases the range of these efforts to get good quality, surplus to requirements educational resources to where they are most be needed be most appreciatedby the recipients

Re: David On Bute Replies

Posted by Jeff Mowatt at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

Let me know if I can help with any of this stuff David. For instance, I can load a copy of your website on my own domain if needed, if others report performance problems. It may just have been my experience at a peak time in the UK, maybe a bottleneck my end.

I can kick off things with a group on Facebook to get others interested. A similar thing is going on amongst a few of us collaborationg around a young guy who runs an orphans football team in uganda and wants to start a conputer club. One of the others has engaged a UK school team to donate their old kit while others collaborate on getting funds together for a computer to be shipped.

If you can get yourself registered with Paypal then you'll be able to set up and promote fundraising appeals, publicise events etc. Networking with schools around the UK and enlarging your circle of contacts to make all aware of the use that could be made of unwanted equipment.

My email if I can do anything for you: jeff.mowatt@btinternet.com

latest update

Posted by Charles "Hipbone" Cameron at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

David Hanschell just sent me another email, and I want to pass on his latest news. He writes:

QUOTE: Yesterday, I was at Ladywood Primary School at 1pm to meet a squad of helpers to load another 40' ocean freight. The logistics went off without a hitch.

And the High Commissioner for Grenada in London has now given me his verbal commitment to assist me in my efforts to help his tri-Island nation state of Grenada, Petit Martinque and Carriacou, suggested I liaise with the Minister of Foreign and Carriacou Affairs, and given me details of five schools on the island of Carriacou that would like to receive the resources which I have in temporary storage at Grange Dock. Everything is provisional in this game, but things are moving forward. :ENDQUOTE

*

In other news, apparently the surplus freight containers he had been offered failed their ISO certification tests, so that particular avenue is closed, at least for now, but David is steaming ahead as keenly as ever.

Thanks, Jeff Mowatt, for your support. Let's see how else we can be of service.

Charles Cameron

Next steps

Posted by Jeff Mowatt at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

With SES for Grenada at http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=5445125901 , having gathered a small group of social entrepreneurs to brainstorm with, it's now a question of finding a revenue stream to cover David's expenditure. Recently I've discovered this social networking medium to be a very affordable advertising medium with it's marketplace sponsored listings and flyers at just $1 for 500 impression.

My feeling is that the funds other than donations might come from a tourist organisation, perhaps one that might offer an affiliate opportunity. The marketplace might also be engaged to appeal for surplus equipment.

Jeff Mowatt

Re: [Jeff] Next steps

Posted by Charles "Hipbone" Cameron at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

Jeff:

Very impressed with the Facebook page you've created at:

http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=5445125901

It was nice to see the Herald article about David and some of his colleagues, too:

http://www.theherald.co.uk/news/focus/display.var.1774598.0.0.php

I'm not too familiar with Facebook. You write about "marketplace sponsored listings and flyers at just $1 for 500 impression". Is this something "inside" Facebook?

And the "ChipIn" app? That looks like something everyone on So cialEdge might like to be aware of. Is that restricted to Facebook? How does it work?

Thanks again for your help.

Those flyers

Posted by Jeff Mowatt at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

Charles, I should have kept my mouth shut, as it seems this bargain has ended. It belongs to the MarketPlace facility within which today switched to a bid based service, like Google. So part of the "social" in social networking looks set to become corporate.

Ours is not the only experiment at this moment. The UK's Channel 4 has been running a "Millionaire' Mission" in Uganda and just yesterday opening a copy of the Guardian one discovers that they too are in on the act, with their one village at a time effort, also in Uganda.

So Charles, the odds may be against us. Now if I could have got through to the Guardian about Kayiwa Fred and his orphans football club in Uganda, that might have made a difference, as would part of the Guardian Media Group who are my customer paying my own social enterprise on time, so that I could do more.

Never mind, we'll press on regardless.

Use Other Volunteers

Posted by kmniazi at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

I was a Rotarian (in Pakistan) and they had this wonderful community of people all over the World, ready to help.

Why not ask people like these (local rotarians, lions etc) to promote this initiative, ask them to identify schools etc in developing countries, who can benefit from this. In addition, you can also ask them for support locally also in this initiative. I would recommend having someone locally, who can help, as online support can get a bit difficult to organize.

Use Other Volunteers

Posted by David Miles Hanschell at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

Hi Kmniazi, Good morning from this Firth of Clyde shore.Many thanks for your comment.Last week I was collecting another ocean freight container load of surplus to requirements educational resources from a Primary School and was staying at the Criagiebield Hotel in Penicuik Midlothian where The Rotary meet every Tuesday ;before i checked out I left information about my project to be handed over totheir chairperson.I hope to get a reply.As time goes by and I press forward with the collection and redistribution of these resources I am building a network of the kind of volunteers you suggest to facilitate more effectively my initiative.

next update

Posted by Charles "Hipbone" Cameron at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

David emailed me the text of a very heart-warming and potentially useful offer he received the other day from someone who had read about his work in the local newspaper. The Development Director of the company in question, ESA McIntosh, wrote:

QUOTE:

We are heavily involved in fitting-out new schools and refurbishing old ones. At present this involves a limited amount of removal or existing fittings and furniture, the vast majority of which goes to landfill.

I would be interested in teaming up with an organisation such as yours to offer our customers the service and satisfaction of knowing that their old furniture and equipment is being re-used.

Is this of interest? If the idea takes off it could involve some very significant volumes and I am not sure of the level of your ambitions for your organisation!

END QUOTE

That's terrific news, and represents a considerable opportunity. I have no doubt that David will do what he can to help, but he clearly needs someone with organizational / business skills to walk him through the processes involved in getting his "organization" out of his own person and into a more reliable and fundable form.

This strikes me as a rare opportunity for the SocialEdge community to support a nascent effort by volunteering those "pieces of the puzzle" at which neither David nor I are skilled.

What's possible here? I'd love to host another event in six months that explores how this "case study" brought together a team that powerfully scaled David's work up...

Next Update

Posted by David Miles Hanschell at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

I would just like to record here now my deep gratitude to Charles for introducing me to the Social Edge Community some time ago (I have been inspired by your dialogue and record of your achievements ) and for the encouragement he has given me to present my initiative at this level; I needed that, for I was somewhat daunted to be and among you learned folk.I must also thank him for articulating precisely the kind of leverage I will require in the days ahead,in order to realise fully the potential promise of my efforts. I look forward to meeting those of you who will help to put the pieces of the puzzle together.I shall endeavour to inform you of developments as they unfold. The-mail from the Development Director of ESA McIntosh http://www.esamcintosh.co.uk came out of the blue yesterday.We work together and share in the fruit of any successes on that front.

Thanks

Posted by Charles "Hipbone" Cameron at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

You're the one we should be thanking, David.

three more updates

Posted by Charles "Hipbone" Cameron at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

Three recent messages from David H:

*

He heard in person from the lady who write the article about him:

QUOTE:

I'm constantly sickened by the amount of waste in our society when people in other parts of the world have so little. I notice that you talk about extending your idea to Africa. I'm involved with an amazing project called the Lewa Wildlife Conservancy in Kenya. … they believe in conserving the local people as well as the local wildlife. One way in which they help is by trying to support a network of local primary schools. I have a particular involvement with one of these schools, following a visit there a few years ago. (My husband and I support the most academically promising pupils to go to secondary school.) The spirit in these schools is fantastic and the children are desperate to learn but they have pathetically little equipment or resources of any kind. Lewa is very well organised and I'm sure that if we could get a container to Nairobi where they have an office, they would undertake to distribute it from there. I've sent out several parcels of equipment for them and everything always arrives intact.

UNQUOTE

*

Two days ago:

Fife Council official phoning to offer Surplus Educational Supplies more surplus to their requirements educational resources.I spent most of the day attempting to source worthy recipients in Uganda and on the Island of Carriacou in the Grenadines .Phoning shipping companies etc.costing the logistics of further shipments. I spoke directly with the Principal of Bishops College in Hillsborough who would be glad to receive a shipments of resources, and indicated ,that so would the rest of her colleagues in the Pre primary,Primary and Secondary schools on that tiny Island ,that was much ravaged by hurricanes Ivan and Emily in 2004 and still very much in a state of recovery, in spite of the big yachts now at anchor off it's palmy shores and tourist board publicity.

*

And today:

Got a taxi up the M8 to the Scottish Exhibition Centre for the Scotland Malawi Tade exhibition This apprentice Social Entrepreneur was networking like it was going out of style.

*

Can anyone offer David help in writing a business analysis / grant proposal?

Good On Yuh Charles!

Posted by David Miles Hanschell at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

I should mention here in relation to a the above comment about a request for business analysis/grant proposal On Monday 29/10/2007 at 3pm I was seeing solicitors in Glasgow who were keen to discuss with me the possibilities and pitfalls of my initiative http://www.burness.co.uk And apart from a welcome,a good cup of coffee and view of cityscape from the 9th floor of a smart new building;the next day I received their intention to formulate, on my behalf, a proposal for a company limited by guarantee and 'the application for recognition of the company, as a charity'to the office of The Scottish Charity Regulator OSCR http://www.oscr.uk This process will take at least three months.At least we have got the ball rolling and i can continue with th enitty gritty of collecting ,storing and arranging to transport surplus educational resources to deserving recipients.

Keeping on keeping on

Posted by Charles "Hipbone" Cameron at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

Just a quick note to say, we're in our fourth and last week on the SocialEdge "front page" here, and if you want to keep this thread spinning, I'd ask you to do two things:

one, bookmark the thread so you can come back here even after the front page mention goes away, and

two, drop a brief note here to let David and myself know of your continuing interest.

One of the things I'd really like to see happening here (in the SE events in general) is the building of a community of folks who recognize each other and make repeat visits. Even a brief "I'm reading along" message of support can help build this sense, so have at it!

I'm reading along, and hoping...

In the news

Posted by Charles "Hipbone" Cameron at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

Dunshalt desks bound for Grenada By Liz Rougvie http://www.fifetoday.co.uk/fife-herald-news/Dunshalt-desks-bound-for-Grenada.3437669.jp

THE controversial closure of Dunshalt Primary School this summer is set to have unexpected benefits for schoolchildren on the other side of the world.

For Dunshalt's desks and chairs could soon be bound for a tiny island off Grenada, where they'll be used in schools ravaged by hurricanes.

It's all part of a charitable initiative called Surplus Educational Supplies, set up two years ago by teacher David Hanschell, who's originally from the West Indies himself but now lives on the island of Bute.

It was while he and his primary four/five pupils were doing a project about the weather in 2004 that Hurricane Ivan struck, killing almost 30 people on Grenada and leaving a trail of devastation in its wake.

Less than a year later, the Caribbean communities took another battering, this time from Hurricane Emily.

The youngsters in Bute rallied round by sending schoolbooks and stationery, inspiring a venture that would capture the imagination of businesses and local authorities throughout Scotland.

David (64) has dug deep into his own pockets to pay for the shipments and has even bought his own containers — but said he had been overwhelmed by the help and support he's been given from Fifers.

CAMPAIGN

Already surplus desks from schools in Kirkcaldy and Inverkeithing have been sent to Grenada, where they've furnished classrooms that would otherwise have remained closed.

As the Fife Herald went to press, David was awaiting official confirmation from Fife Council that he could have the furniture from Dunshalt, but a spokesman said it was very likely.

The authority closed the doors of the tiny, seven-pupil school in Dunshalt in spite of a vigorous campaign by angry parents to save it.

"I hope the blow will be softened somewhat by the fact that its resources will be put to very good use," said David.

"It's sad that it's closed, but its closure literally means that another school will be able to stay open.

"I have spoken to the teachers on the little island of Carriacou and they are delighted at the prospect of receiving equipment from Scotland, and send their heartfelt thanks."

Villagers said that while they were still aggrieved about the school's closure, they were pleased that good had come from the situation and that others' lives would be made better.

They have also offered David around 60 surplus stacking chairs from the village hall.

In The News Again

Posted by David Miles Hanschell at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

Thanks for passing that on Charles. Some good news. This afternoon I spoke to the supplier of ocean freight ISO plated containers in quantities who will let me have them at a better rate than North of the border.I am to contact him after Christmas. I am also currently attempting to source storage for my containers either nearer to the Port of Felixstowe( the largest ocean freight terminal in Europe or possibly in the port of Southhampton area). I guess I'll have to bite the bullet, as the saying goes and move own myself and ambitions up a notch.I can't hang around and wait for business social venture capitalist angels to underwrite my efforts. HE helps those who help themselves.Well, up to a point and beyond that I assume there are The Good Guys and Lassies who are are out there somewhere waiting to meet me hauf way as there have been ever since i began this safari.

Fresh News

Posted by David Miles Hanschell at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

The Fife Council Estates department have just offered Surplus Educational Supplies 2000 square feet on a temporary basis in one of their industrial warehouse storage units in Glenrothes; which if you read this, and look at a map, you will see is not far from the village of Dunshalt . This will allow a breathing space until such time as I can get a container there to be loaded and transferred to Grange on the Firth of Forth; to be loaded on to the feeder vessel M.V Clonlee for Rotterdamn and for Kingston Jamaica and on to St George's Grenada.Get yer atlases oot children!

Fresh news Editor error/omission

Posted by David Miles Hanschell at May 07, 2009 11:08 PM

Grange Dock Grangemouth